Even Joseph thought Mary's virgin birth story was iffy, and at one point was so sure Mary had lain with another that he was ready to divorce her. For these gifts those persons long for who seek earthly things; but I seek nothing earthly, nothing carnal. It seems that the biggest arguments for the perpetual virginity comes from the church fathers, but the points they make are not backed by scripture. A strong defender of the doctrine was St. It is known for all eternity, that God would send His Son into the world to enable our fallen nature to be once more redeemed so that we might dwell with Him forever in eternity again. Clearly you cannot accept the hard teaching of Christ that being chaste, abstinent, or remaining a virgin for Him is preferred. Paul more likely is referring to the second James who was an apostle, according to Luke 6:
Did Jewish Temple Virgins Exist and was Mary a Temple Virgin?
Therefore, we can see that the word "until" is used in different contexts; and it is not appropriate to look to other persons to see how the word is used and transfer the meaning of that word to Matt. Mary's virginity and Matt. I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic. The History of Joseph the Carpenter. All the Author is doing is telling all sorts of people how futile the situation is of Zion. So these women are not simply hanging out around the Temple, looking for men, gossiping, or chatting about the weather. Harper San Francisco,
Virginity of Mary Dogma : University of Dayton, Ohio
MacArthur says, "Further evidence that these were Jesus' actual brothers comes from Psalm This was without the cooperation of a man, and she remained a virgin after that"; and that " Christ. A Catholic Evangelical Debate. Washbourne, LTE, p.
All About Mary
Description: The Greek usage here obviously reflects the underlying Hebrew in which 'ah means both blood brother and ' kinsman. The Creation of Feminist Consciousness. The New American Bible attests: Hill  argue that this implies that Mary and Joseph had customary marital relations after the birth of Jesus. Now it will first be necessary to show what previous reason there was for the Son of God's being born of a virgin.